index
Free shipping on orders over $75 Shop now
—

  • SAVE 20%

  • Where Every Bite is a Celebration

SHOP NOW!

  • Save 50% Off

  • Baking Happiness, One Slice at a Time

SHOP NOW!

BEST SELLER

Melanie's Mikyway Bundt cake - Cookie Creation By Mary Melanie's Mikyway Bundt cake - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Melanie's Milky Way Bundt Cake is a decadent, chocolate cake filled with... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary Melanie's Mikyway Bundt cake
$40.00 $47.00
layer bars - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Dive into layers of indulgence with our Layer Bars from Creative Cookies... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary layer bars
$39.00 $45.00
Gingerbread Bundt - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Warm up your holidays with our delightful Gingerbread Bundt! Bursting with the... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary Gingerbread Bundt
$35.00 $40.00
Marble - Cookie Creation By Mary Marble - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Treat yourself to a swirl of sweetness with our Marble from Creative Cookies... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary Marble
$39.00 $42.00
Spiced pear Bundt - Cookie Creation By Mary Spiced pear Bundt - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Our Spiced Pear Bundt Cake is a warm, aromatic treat made with... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary Spiced pear Bundt
$35.00 $40.00
Turtle Bundt Cake - Cookie Creation By Mary Turtle Bundt Cake - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Our Turtle Bundt Cake is a rich, indulgent treat filled with layers of caramel,... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary Turtle Bundt Cake
$45.00 $59.00
Caramel Bundt cake - Cookie Creation By Mary Caramel Bundt cake - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Our Caramel Bundt Cake is a rich, moist cake drizzled with smooth,... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary Caramel Bundt cake
$40.00 $48.00
SHOP ALL
Free shipping
Get free shipping on orders of $100 or more
Refer a friend
Refer a friend and get 15% off each other
Secure payment
Your payment information is processed securely

new collection

Banana Bundt cake - Cookie Creation By Mary Banana Bundt cake - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Our Banana Bundt Cake is a moist, flavorful treat made with ripe bananas, creating... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary Banana Bundt cake
$35.00 $40.00
M&M cake k jit kat Border - Cookie Creation By Mary M&M cake k jit kat Border - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Our M&M Cake with Kit Kat Border is a fun and colorful... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary M&M cake k jit kat Border
$47.00 $55.00
Lemon Blueberry Iced Loaf - Cookie Creation By Mary Lemon Blueberry Iced Loaf - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Our Lemon Blueberry Iced Loaf is a refreshing treat, featuring a moist... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary Lemon Blueberry Iced Loaf
$39.00 $45.00
Caramel Bundt cake - Cookie Creation By Mary Caramel Bundt cake - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Our Caramel Bundt Cake is a rich, moist cake drizzled with smooth,... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary Caramel Bundt cake
$40.00 $48.00
Candy apples - Cookie Creation By Mary Candy apples - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Our Candy Apples are a sweet, crunchy treat featuring crisp apples coated in a... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary Candy apples
$35.00 $40.00
Butterfinger Bundt cake - Cookie Creation By Mary Butterfinger Bundt cake - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Our Butterfinger Bundt Cake is a rich, moist cake filled with chunks... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary Butterfinger Bundt cake
$40.00 $46.00

Moments Away from Cake Heaven! Countdown's On!

Delicious Creations, Just a Bite Away!

Sweetness Awaits! Countdown to Cake Bliss

Gingerbread Bundt - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Warm up your holidays with our delightful Gingerbread Bundt! Bursting with the... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary Gingerbread Bundt
$35.00 $40.00
Candy Cane Swirls - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Celebrate the season with our Candy Cane Swirls cake! This festive creation... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary Candy Cane Swirls
$40.00 $45.00
peppermint - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Celebrate the season with our Peppermint Candy Cane Swirls cake! This festive... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary peppermint
$38.00 $44.00
cherry chocolate Bundt cake - Cookie Creation By Mary
Quickshop Indulge in the irresistible combination of rich chocolate and sweet, juicy cherries... Compare Add to Cart
Cookie Creation By Mary cherry chocolate Bundt cake
$40.00 $70.00

Fresh Finds

Sweets & Treats

7 Items

Sweet Indulgences

6 Items

Classic Comforts

11 Items

All Products

ABOUT US

Welcome to CreativeCookiesByMary, where every cake is a masterpiece! Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply indulging in a sweet treat, we offer a wide range of delicious, custom-designed cakes made with the finest ingredients. From classic flavors to unique creations, each cake is crafted with love and creativity to make your moments even sweeter.

Sign up & save 15%

© 2025, Cookie Creation By Mary. All rights reserved.
  • PayPal
  • Venmo
    Verified